For an amendment to be in order, what must it always be?

For an amendment to be in order, it must always be germane, which means it must be relevant to the subject matter under discussion. This requirement ensures that any proposed changes to a motion remain focused on the original topic, allowing for a coherent and logical progression of the meeting.

If amendments were allowed that are not germane, it could lead to confusion, distraction, and a lack of clarity in the discussion. By keeping amendments relevant, it ensures that all members can follow the conversation and understand how changes may affect the outcome of the original motion. This principle is fundamental in parliamentary procedure to maintain order and facilitate effective discussions.

While formal, unanimous, and debatable characteristics may apply to amendments under certain circumstances, it is the germane quality that is universally required for an amendment to be considered valid and in order.